PET vs. PETG in Packaging: What’s the Difference?

Packaging is a critical component in a wide range of markets, especially within the personal care, home care, and health care industries. In these sectors, not only is the visual appeal of packaging essential, but also its durability, protective capabilities, and suitability for various products. Two materials commonly used are PET (Polyethylene Terephthalate) and PETG (Polyethylene Terephthalate Glycol). Let’s explore the differences between these materials and their application within these specific markets.

1. Barrier Properties & Product Protection:

• PET: PET possesses excellent barrier properties against water vapour and oxygen, making it an ideal choice for personal care products like shampoos, lotions, and cosmetics. Its protective nature also ensures that home care products, such as cleaning agents, remain intact and effective.
• PETG: While PETG has decent barrier properties, they’re slightly inferior to PET. In the health care sector, it might be chosen for packaging where clarity is more important than prolonged shelf-life, such as medical tools or first-aid components.

2. Clarity and Aesthetics:

• PET: Offers clear and bright packaging, which is attractive for personal care and home care products where product visibility can drive purchasing decisions.
• PETG: Provides even greater clarity and glossiness compared to PET. In the health care market, where product visibility is essential, especially for products like medical solutions or syringes, PETG can be the preferred choice.

3. Durability & Safety:

• PET: It’s strong and robust, suitable for packaging products in the home care market where containers might be subjected to rough handling. Its chemical resistance also ensures the contents remain uncontaminated.
• PETG: With its superior impact resistance, PETG packaging is less prone to cracking or breaking. This is crucial in the health care industry where the integrity of the product, such as medications or medical devices, is paramount.

4. Forming & Design Flexibility:

• PET: Though slightly harder to thermoform than PETG, PET can be moulded into a variety of shapes and designs suitable for personal care products, from slender perfume bottles to large containers for bath products.
• PETG: Its ease of thermoforming allows for intricate designs, making it a favourite for premium personal care products or specialised health care packages.

5. Chemical Resistance:

• PET: Offers resistance to a wide range of chemicals, making it ideal for home care products like detergents and disinfectants, ensuring the packaging won’t degrade or leach.
• PETG: While it also has good chemical resistance, certain compounds, especially those with high alcohol content, might affect its integrity. It’s essential to test the compatibility of the product with PETG packaging.

6. Cost & Sustainability:

• PET: Being more common, PET usually comes at a slightly lower price point and is highly recyclable, which appeals to brands looking for sustainable packaging solutions in the personal and home care sectors.
• PETG: While it might cost more, its unique properties justify its use in niche applications, especially within the health care industry. However, recycling rates for PETG are generally lower than PET.

The choice between PET and PETG depends on the specific requirements of the product being packaged. While PET remains a favourite for many personal and home care products due to its cost-effectiveness and protective qualities, PETG’s enhanced clarity and durability make it stand out, especially in the health care sector. Brands must weigh the pros and cons of each material in the context of their product needs and market expectations.

You may enjoy reading:

Why is PET a Good Packaging Material?

The Versatility and Benefits of HDPE Containers

BlueSky thinking, ‘Post-Consumer Recycled (PCR) PET’